“Most of Special Relatvity is like playing a game of – He said, She said.”
Inspired by the recent Pokemon movie trailer, this post takes you on a journey with Ash and Pikachu as they find out about the founding principles of special relativity – Length contraction, Time dilation and Lorentz Transformation.
Let’s consider a scenario where Pikachu is on a car moving with a velocity and Ash is standing the ground.
There is a Pokeball on the floor of the car. It is constantly emitting light straight toward the ceiling, Let us try to understand how Ash and Pikachu would see this photon of light from the time it leaves the floor to the ceiling and back, in their respective frame of references:
How pikachu describes the event:
Pikachu only sees the photon bouncing up and down and therefore:
How Ash describes the event:
But when the trajectory of the light is viewed from Ash’s frame of reference it is not a straight line at all and therefore, according to Ash:
Since both these descriptions of what happened are true and have to agree, we must therefore from (1) and (2) have that,
This ensures that both the event descriptions are satisfied. The implication being that Pikachu who is on a cart moving with some velocity has to be experiencing time slower than someone who is not moving at all (Ash).
Consider the same scenario as before except that this time the Pokeball is emitting light along the direction of motion and back.
How Pikachu describes the event:
If the time measured by Pikachu is slower than Ash from the previous analysis, then we expect that the distance traveled by the photon in Pikachu’s frame of reference will not be . Instead let’s call that distance . Therefore,
How Ash describes the event:
According to Ash, the photon was initially moving along the direction of motion and then started moving against the direction of motion and therefore the total time taken would be the addition of the time taken in both the cases i.e
But, we found from our previous analysis that and
. Plugging these back into the previous equation gives us:
The length of the cart as observed by Ash () is shorter than that observed by Pikachu (). This implies that if Pikachu is holding a 1-meter stick, then Ash would see the 1-meter stick to be shorter than 1-meter. And in general any object that is held parallel to the direction of motion would appear ‘squished’
Now consider the final scenario where at , the pokeball is at a distance from both of them and emits a photon of light. Pikachu decides to move towards the pokeball with a velocity to catch it before Ash does.
This pulse of light would reach Pikachu when he is at a distance from the Pokeball and would reach Ash at a distance since he is not moving.
Length contraction according to Ash:
Having understood the concept of Length contraction, Ash would say:
Length contraction according to Pikachu:
But Pikachu also understands Length Contraction and thinks that he is at rest and it is Ash who is receding backwards. And therefore:
We must understand that both are valid representations of what is happening and must agree. Therefore plugging in (4) into the above equation and performing some simple algebraic manipulations we get,
(4) and (5) are known as Lorentz Transform equations and relate the distances and time measured in Ash’s reference frame with that measured in Pikachu’s frame.
One can start off in Ash’s frame of reference and perform a “Lorentz Boost” to see how things are happening in Pikachu’s frame of reference. Often it is convenient to write them in a matrix form:
In this post we have constrained Pikachu to move only in the x-direction but this need not be the case. A fun little exercise would be to extend this analysis to Lorentz boosts in 3-dimensions.
It is often more enlightening to see these relations when applied to problems and my personal recommendation would be the book – ‘Spacetime physics by Edwin F. Taylor’. Thank you for joining Ash and Pikachu on this journey. Hope you learned something new. Have fun!